.对《Communism》的笔记(1)

.
. (Being a superfluous woman)

读过 Communism

Communism
  • 书名: Communism
  • 作者: Leslie Holmes
  • 副标题: A Very Short Introduction
  • 出版社: Oxford University Press, USA
  • 出版年: 2009-09-21
  • 笔记摘选

    P133:

    One other possible legitimation mode for the Communists was system performance, meaning that they would seek the right to rule by delivering what the people wanted. Unfortunately, the economic slowdowns of the 1970s and 1980s rendered this path problematic. Moreover, attempts to redress the balance between heavy and light industry – and thus between the defence needs of the state and the consumer needs of citizens – had been at best only partial in most Communist states. Many citizens looked to the West, and saw that lifestyles and access to goods were much better there. Since their own leaderships had essentially put the end goal of communism on the back burner by the 1970s with their talk of ‘realistic socialism’ and acknowledgement of shortages, economic performance could not serve the legitimizing function leaders had hoped it would.
    引自 笔记摘选

    P135:

    A system can tolerate such a fundamental contradiction as long as the economy is functioning well. In other words, many citizens in most types of system appear to be willing to tolerate limits on their political freedoms as long as their standards of living are increasing, their security is ensured, and they are reasonably free to travel. These preconditions have pertained in China for more than two decades. But if the Chinese economy were to experience a serious crisis, there are many precedents to suggest that the political system could fail. However, we need to consider the possibility that Chinese Communist power collapses, and that whatever succeeds it is, at least in the short term, unlikely to be a model others will seek to learn from or emulate. To conclude this brief analysis of Communism, it is finally time to acknowledge the elephant in the room – social democracy. In most countries in which voters were free to choose, social democracy proved to be more popular in the 20th century than Communism. The type of system Sweden had until the late 1980s – when even the Swedes began to move towards neo-liberalism – provides concrete evidence that it is possible to combine high levels of security, prosperity, the rule of law, freedom, and democracy. The hybrid has existed and could well return. For numerous reasons, it is both more desirable and more likely that it will experience a re-birth than that Communism will. But then that is how dialectics operate!
    引自 笔记摘选

    对于共产主义未来的发展,作者给出的回答没什么新意,四平八稳。不过前几章对于共产主义简要的历史回顾,以及对于共产主义陷落的分析,读者不难读出要害所在。Legitimation crisis theory这一节,作者引用了马克思韦伯的理论,分析了共产主义国家试图从traditional, charismatic or legal-rational mode to legitimize the state所遇到的困境。这当然只是一种切入角度,也不妨于此去理解眼下的种种活动与宣传之目的何在。

    2015-03-01 13:46:11 回应

.的其他笔记  · · · · · ·  ( 全部356条 )

The American Cause
1
The Founding Fathers and the Place of Religion in America
1
What is History? And Other Essays
1
Science Fiction, Ethics and the Human Condition
1
Mortal Questions
1
The Conservative Mind
1
Exit Right
1
Every Time I Find the Meaning of Life, They Change It
1
Morality and Politics in Modern Europe
1
The Conservative Intellectual Movement in America Since 1945
1
Armed in America
1
Self to Self
2
Love
3
The Philosophy of Umberto Eco
1
Liberalism’s Religion
1
The Oxford Handbook of Reproductive Ethics
1
Andersen's Fairy Tales
1
Categories and De Interpretatione
1
The Rights Turn in Conservative Christian Politics
1
The Ante-Nicene Fathers
1
Chosen Peoples
1
The Banalization of Nihilism
1
Philosophy Within Its Proper Bounds
2
自由的忠诚
2
被淹没和被拯救的
1
The State and the Self
1
Living Words
1
严寒来自克里姆林宫
1
Consciousness in Locke
1
Do All Persons Have Equal Moral Worth?
1
白氏长庆集
1
Philosophy Between the Lines
1
无敌舰队
1
战士的荣耀
1
朝服
1
基督教新约伦理学
1
一切都在流动
2
谈虎集
4
基督教旧约伦理学
2
Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy
2
布拉格精神
1
Expulsions
1
穆旦诗全集
1
Parenting to a Degree
1
樂府詩集(全四冊)
1
Common Errors in English Usage
1
New Concise Handbook
1
Kant and Applied Ethics
1
Ancient Philosophy of the Self
1
俄罗斯笑话与幽默
1
Persons and Bodies
1
Making Sense of Humanity
1
Public Reason Confucianism
1
大裂
1
Self and World
1
Moral Responsibility and Ontology
1
Handbook of Phenomenology and Cognitive Science
1
The Oxford Handbook of the Self
2
Time and Identity
1
Reasons and Persons
1
Mental Time Travel
1
Life, Death, and Meaning
1
生物与非生物之间
1
Elements of Argument
1
自由主义与荣誉
1
帝国的分裂
1
最后的中华帝国:大清
1
A Materialist Metaphysics of the Human Person
1
An Essay Concerning Human Understanding
1
Four-Dimensionalism
1
Theodicy
2
The Theory of Democracy Revisited
1
历史理性批判文集
1
实践理性批判
1
Critique of Practical Reason
1
The Metaphysics of Morals
1
论信望爱
1
倫理學.對話
3
A Reforming People
1
自由与传统
1
五四以来汉语书面语言的变迁和发展
1
法国革命论
1
马基雅维里时刻
1
美利坚共和国的缔造
3
西方政治传统
2
民主德国的秘密读者
2
Two Treatises of Government and A Letter Concerning Toleration
1
罗素传
2
Conservatism
1
Wise Choices, Apt Feelings
1
Religion, Politics, and the Moral Life (Selected Writings of Michael Oakeshott)
1
阁楼上的疯女人
1
独抒己见
1
The Ethics of Care
2
基督宗教伦理学(上下卷)
1
The Road since Structure
1
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
1
Conceptual Revolutions
1
Personal Identity
1
The Mysterious Flame
1
雅各布·克莱因思想史文集
1
罗素传
5
伦理学
2
人不单靠面包活着
1
Morality
2
伊西斯的面纱
1
赤地之戀
1
Metaethics after Moore
1
Theory and Reality
1
Moral Luck
1
易经
1
实验哲学导论
1
涉渡之舟
1
无限与视角
5
证明与反驳
1
Philosophy of Science
1
Webster's New World Letter Writing Handbook
2
The Language of Morals
1
叶嘉莹说汉魏六朝诗
1
Routledge Philosophy GuideBook to Hume on Morality
4
Inside The Centre
3
泽泻集 过去的生命
2
An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals
2
樂章集校注
1
The Meaning of Life
1
人生的意义
1
Analytic Philosophy: An Anthology
9
脂砚斋重评石头记甲戌校本
3
薛涛诗笺(修订本)
1
蔣捷詞校注
3
Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals
1
道德形而上学的奠基
1
清嘉录
2
彭加勒
1
Moral Discourse and Practice
4
稼轩词编年笺注(增订本)
3
An Introduction to Karl Marx
5
Hilbert
5
I Want to Be a Mathematician
2
The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Mathematics and Logic
1
Prime Obsession
4
韦应物集校注
11
Engines of Logic
1
Stylish Academic Writing
7
The Elements of Style, Fourth Edition
3
到芬兰车站
2
Philosophical Writing
7
魏晋玄学论稿
3
Runaway
2
卡廷惨案真相
2
马克思与西方政治思想传统
4
自由主义、社群与文化
1
或此或彼
12
解构的共通体
1
叔本华思想随笔
2
生存哲学
6
哲学史教程(下卷)
18
Mathematics
1
数理哲学导论
2
马克思主义的起源
2
对德意志民族的演讲
4
德意志史 第三卷
1
西方哲学原著选读(下卷)
1
文艺复兴和17世纪理性主义
1
维特根斯坦传
2
古希腊哲学史纲
3
哲学史教程(上卷)
8
鼠疫
1
荷尔德林诗的阐释
2
The Picture of Dorian Gray
3
我的童话人生
1
亲吻神学
2
中世纪的秋天
1
论道德与文学
3
Teleny or The Reverse of the Medal
1
夜读抄
1
致死的疾病
3
爱因斯坦的梦
1
论自由意志
4
接触
2
唐才子传校笺 第5册
1
沿海岸線徵友
2
斯宾诺莎的理性启蒙
1
庄子纂笺
1
大众的反叛
2
一间自己的房间
1
女权辩护 妇女的屈从地位
1
第二性Ⅱ
1