This comprehensive survey of the history of the Church in Western Europe, considers the Church both as a set of institutions and as a spiritual body. The first half concentrates on the structures of religious belief and practice in the period 900-1050; the second half concentrates on the revolutionary changes associated with the rise of the papacy to an ascended level of ruler-ship. It shows how far one can talk of a 'reform movement', and how the idea and ideal of papal monarchy became both the prisoner and the leader of those who sought for a renewal of Christian life. Tellenbach's survey is the work of a scholar who has been working in the field for over 60 years. It is characterised by the freshness and maturity of its judgments, which cut through many fashionable theories. No other work on this topic offers comparable range, depth and authority.
3 有用 海上心史 2015-06-17 18:07:38
传统德国学派的解读,对于利奥九世的作用看的很准。自己感觉比美国的通行那版更有代表性,也更好看。史料扎实之外,在字里行间颇有一种寓褒贬于论断的风格。绝对政教之争必读书啊。
1 有用 roylouis 2025-11-12 23:26:57 北京
反思传统叙事的政教之争,核心是Investiture Conflict,所以个人感觉和标题略有出入。10世纪是当作背景在叙述。全景式的梳理限于背景的构建,但依旧说清了很多模糊的点。 区分“神圣化”和“神职人员化”,认为君主制的存在必然性地保有君权神授。整个政教之争的过程是依赖于诸多的具体事件的实践。
0 有用 paupertas 2026-01-13 20:48:09 北京
时至今日,Tellenbach这本书仍然给格里高利改革研究提供了一个基本叙事框架,供学者不断调整修正。也就是说,几乎不太需要读比这本更早的书。个人感觉前半部分讲proprietary church system和利奥九世改革非常有收获,之后讲政教之争明显叙事变多,对结构性的探讨减少,略显遗憾。