严重此书是伪科学书籍

　作者：蚂蚁
　　
　　 网上闲逛时候看到一帖的标题：看了这本书之后我啥都不敢喝了，只是拼命
　　的灌水。好奇之下进去看了看，说是一本名叫《水这样喝可以治病》的书。一看
　　这书名就感觉有问题，貌似跟以前见过的一本什么《水知道答案》一类的书。为
　　了确认，随便搜了一下，当当卓越都有卖，如
　　http://product.dangdang.com/product.aspx?product_id=9250600，一看几个
　　评论就知道果然是这样的货色：
　　
　　 《水是最好的药》姊妹篇，一颗医学原子弹！
　　世上最伟大的健康发现。——山姆·彼瑟，自然疗法大学
　　我相信，50年后这仍然是一本绝对经典的健康书。
　　——菲利普·戴，英国作家和健康调查记者
　　
　　于是再随便搜一下。
　　
　　原书
　　http://www.amazon.com/Water-Health-Healing-Youre-Thirsty/dp/0446690740
　　看介绍：
　　Editorial Reviews
　　From Publishers Weekly
　　The author, a physician trained in Iran (Your Body's Many Cries for
　　Water), not only believes that drinking water is healthy, but makes
　　extravagant claims for its curative powers.
　　
　　作者叫 F. Batmanghelidj ，看这名字，是美国的医学博士？
　　再用他名字随便搜一下，比如看看这个页面吧
　　http://www.quackwatch.com/11Ind/batman.html
　　
　　"Full-time Research"
　　Batmanghelidj claimed that he did more than 20 years of full-time
　　research and that his findings achieved worldwide acclaim. His Web
　　site states that he "has presented his findings at several
　　international and world conferences, and they have been published and
　　peer-reviewed in a number of scientific journals." [4] However, the
　　world's largest medical research database (Medline) lists only two
　　entries for "Batmanghelidj." The first is a 3-page editorial, "A New
　　and Natural Method of Treatment of Peptic Ulcer Disease," which was
　　published in 1983 the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology [6]. The
　　other, titled "Pain: A Need for Paradigm Change," reflects a lecture
　　he gave in Greece in 1987 that was published in Anticancer Research [7].
　　Neither of these documents would be appropriately described as a
　　research report. The first one states that from November 1979 through
　　May 1982, while imprisoned in Iran, he treated over 3,000 fellow
　　prisoners with "ulcer symptoms" and was able to follow the progress of
　　about 600 of them with information "from guards, physicians in charge
　　of other sections, and chance meetings or messages received." The
　　second paper presents no additional data but contains a "theoretical
　　discussion" of why he believes "water deficiency" is a major cause of
　　disease.
　　
　　 很显然，这人不过是国外的一个大忽悠而已。国内搞出版的一些人不知道是
　　自己水平太差还是反正可以赚钱，拿这种玩意来出，还真能忽悠国内一些人买书，
　　还真有人信。没办法，中国人太多，想忽悠一些人总是可以的。
　　
　　 BTW：让偶很生气的是在卓越发这评论被删。
　　
　　(XYS20080707)
　　
----------------------------------------------------------


顶你的！！！！！！！！！！！