钱理群说智慧是一种丰富的痛苦。苏格拉底说unexamined life is not worth living. Arendt说的平庸之恶就是放弃这种痛苦，放弃思考和对“对与错”的判断。读Arendt有一种奇特的痛感，看她一层一层剖开我们对“morality”，“对和错”的认识，哪怕留下血淋淋的伤口也绝不停止，因为thinking是每个人避免平庸之恶的唯一方法，judgment是行使个人自由的唯一方法。最后记住她频频引用苏格拉底的一句话：It's better to suffer wrong than to do wrong.
a great book. gave me some answers on the moral issues, what is right and wrong, and how to "tell" right from wrong. in deed, the banality of evil is the shocking evil.
9 有用 foxyroxy 2016-11-21 00:13:30
钱理群说智慧是一种丰富的痛苦。苏格拉底说unexamined life is not worth living. Arendt说的平庸之恶就是放弃这种痛苦，放弃思考和对“对与错”的判断。读Arendt有一种奇特的痛感，看她一层一层剖开我们对“morality”，“对和错”的认识，哪怕留下血淋淋的伤口也绝不停止，因为thinking是每个人避免平庸之恶的唯一方法，judgment是行使个人自由的唯一方法。最后记住她频频引用苏格拉底的一句话：It's better to suffer wrong than to do wrong.
0 有用 Don Quixote 2022-02-16 13:55:28
a great book. gave me some answers on the moral issues, what is right and wrong, and how to "tell" right from wrong. in deed, the banality of evil is the shocking evil.
0 有用 丁萌 2022-03-04 17:29:11
一些概念辨析显得有用但任意
0 有用 haowen 2022-04-24 10:52:47
補標。Politics本科必讀書目。一直以為早就標過了，居然是我記錯了🤦♀️我的錯
0 有用 sachroon 2020-04-29 08:59:37
看了前面一半，讲到thinking and moral consideration的时候感觉有点欧哲味道了？
0 有用 ethan 2017-10-18 05:53:28
从根源上批判西方形而上学，认为基督教伦理和康德主义都遵循命令/接受的纵向结构，将避免做价值判断当做美德，这导致了纳粹的极恶。极恶本身也是平庸之恶，犯下罪行的是很多拒绝思考，拒绝判断，拒绝记忆的“非人”。思考/判断是现代每个人的责任。（漏洞也很明显，思考的能力和标准哪儿来的？）
0 有用 Мишка 2019-05-12 16:27:55
推荐collective responsibility一章，彻底讨论了一些在Arendt的Jewish Writings和EJ出现过的collective guilt问题。
0 有用 马耶！ 2024-05-19 14:31:08 中国香港
Sharp and sincere as always