In 1994, workers broke ground on China’s Three Gorges Dam. By its completion in 2012, the dam had transformed the ecology of the Yangzi River, displaced over a million people, and forever altered a landscape immortalized in centuries of literature and art. The controversial history of the dam is well known; what this book uncovers are its unexpected connections to the cultural traditions it seems to sever. By reconsidering the dam in relation to the aesthetic history of the Three Gorges region over more than two millennia, Fixing Landscape offers radically new ways of thinking about cultural and spatial production in contemporary China.
Corey Byrnes argues that this monumental feat of engineering can only be understood by confronting its status as a techno-poetic act, a form of landscaping indebted to both the technical knowledge of engineers and to the poetic legacies of the Gorges as cultural site. Synthesizing methods drawn from premodern, modern, and contemporary Chinese studies, as well as from critical geography, art history, and the environmental humanities, Byrnes offers innovative readings of eighth-century poetry, paintings from the twelfth through twenty-first centuries, contemporary film, nineteenth-century British travelogues, and Chinese and Western maps, among other sources. Fixing Landscape shows that premodern poetry and visual art have something urgent to tell us about a contemporary experiment in spatial production. Poems and paintings may not build dams, but Byrnes argues that the Three Gorges Dam would not exist as we know it without them.
1 有用 esoteric 2020-11-18 22:33:03
同觉得正文没有序言那么精彩和令人激动,主要关注共和国的三峡吧,理论上不是很强
2 有用 L 2019-04-22 11:19:31
(Overly) interpretational, imaginative, and ambitious 宋朝人苦寻杜甫故居这个事儿倒是很有意思
0 有用 silhouette 2025-12-06 20:35:24 北京
这样一个题材的书注定是没法让人满意的吧,但是想法挺好的,而且虽然一眼看去是生态批评,但其实通篇充满empathy,伦理性甚至胜过景观的物质性和地理性。虽然对景观的“亲历”与这本书背道而驰,但还是读得我想坐船沿着三峡漂荡了。
2 有用 蚂蚁有问题 2023-07-06 03:30:22 加拿大
前两章没读。第三章分析游记,第四章讨论船工,后两章聚焦作品(三峡好人和Yun-fei Ji的画作)。不过一直没看到从intro就说的孙中山、毛等对三峡改造的细节。最后一章的精彩大部分源自Ji的作品本身的精彩,而不在于阐释的精彩。不过对水库系列的研究还是很有借鉴意义,具体建设时期的labour问题值得深挖。
3 有用 やす 2020-11-09 10:31:46
「想像力こそ、世界を変える。」// 罕見的環境史和eco criticism的合成獸,這選題太容易寫得不倫不類,領域跨度也很大。Byrnes在intro把這個餅畫得太好了。aesthetics和再現justify了對物質和景觀的改造這個論點很喜歡,然後fixed landscape又進入新的美學循環生生不息。作為methodological experiment確實相當有參考價值。實際章節里觀感不... 「想像力こそ、世界を変える。」// 罕見的環境史和eco criticism的合成獸,這選題太容易寫得不倫不類,領域跨度也很大。Byrnes在intro把這個餅畫得太好了。aesthetics和再現justify了對物質和景觀的改造這個論點很喜歡,然後fixed landscape又進入新的美學循環生生不息。作為methodological experiment確實相當有參考價值。實際章節里觀感不太妙,為了扣題有些部分如ch1.2拼接痕跡過重,ahistorical的寫法需要斟酌。ch.3關於national landscape的論述比較精彩,但再往後看深感檔案的不平衡,poetic比techno多太多了,「改造」這個核心論點大多靠腦補⋯//致谢秀恩爱猝不及防被糊了一臉狗糧 (展开)