How our medical obsessions and the image of the body influence modern architecture. This book explores the impact of medical discourse and diagnostic technologies on the formation, representation and reception of modern architecture. It challenges the normal understanding of modern architecture by proposing that the architecture of the early 20th century was shaped by the dominant medical obsession of its time: tuberculosis and its primary diagnostic tool, the X-ray. If architectural discourse has from its beginning associated building and body, the body that it describes is the medical body, reconstructed by each new theory of health. Modern architects presented their architecture as a kind of medical instrument for protecting and enhancing the body. X-ray technology and modern architecture were born around the same time and evolved in parallel. While the X-ray exposed the inside of the body to the public eye, the modern building unveiled its interior, inverting the relationship between private and public. Colomina suggests that if we want to talk about the state of the art in buildings, we should look to the dominant obsessions about illness and the latest techniques of imaging the body―and ask what effects they may have on the way we conceive architecture.
1 有用 sixland 2021-06-14 22:05:37
有趣的角度,从身体-心灵和媒介的角度看建筑史,只是读的时候感觉写的过于轻松了,只是换了个角度理解现代建筑史,觉得有联系的文学文本、精神分析内容都直接拿来用,也没有利用媒介来拓宽话题边界。前三章串起来那些我们熟悉的建筑文本,又和图像、医学史联动,看起来很新鲜。第四章写SANAA的看的令人不适…是我太敏感了吗,觉得西方中心主义色彩好浓,动不动就“这个设计细节让我们重新回想起了密斯”,但第五章还挺喜欢的... 有趣的角度,从身体-心灵和媒介的角度看建筑史,只是读的时候感觉写的过于轻松了,只是换了个角度理解现代建筑史,觉得有联系的文学文本、精神分析内容都直接拿来用,也没有利用媒介来拓宽话题边界。前三章串起来那些我们熟悉的建筑文本,又和图像、医学史联动,看起来很新鲜。第四章写SANAA的看的令人不适…是我太敏感了吗,觉得西方中心主义色彩好浓,动不动就“这个设计细节让我们重新回想起了密斯”,但第五章还挺喜欢的,虽然私人公共边界模糊、建筑变成信息等论点都不新,但是从媒介角度分析的还挺精彩。总的来说值得一读 (展开)
0 有用 soda 2021-06-27 16:15:34
文笔好,两天刷刷读完。内容高开低走……脑子好使开头引人入胜但是没有信仰最后结语全面崩塌……
0 有用 narcissisheep 2021-08-11 12:11:31
似乎是两条可以独立理解的线索,一个是关于被建筑空间维护的健康的身体(疗养院),另一个是关于被建筑媒介再现的透明的身体(X光)。都是有意思的议题,但对于"疾病与建筑的关系"这一开篇提出的主题,总觉得前者过于贴切而显得没那么新颖,后者却又不那么相关……
1 有用 FoundObject 2020-12-21 11:38:16
Architecture as a cure-->sick building syndrome. X-Ray造成的Privacy与Publicity之间的模糊和互相渗透。很好看,但是surveilance这个概念出现数次,却没有怎么讨论surveilance与Privacy和publicity之间的关系。
0 有用 fuehjda 2023-07-12 01:00:07 英国
4年后写论文终于看了,没想到啊没想到。