George III, Britain's longest-reigning king, has gone down in history as 'the cruellest tyrant of this age' (Thomas Paine, eighteenth century), 'a sovereign who inflicted more profound and enduring injuries upon this country than any other modern English king' (WEH Lecky, nineteenth century), 'one of England's most disastrous kings' (JH Plumb, twentieth century) and as the pompous, camp and sinister monarch of the musical 'Hamilton' (twenty-first century).
Andrew Roberts's magnificent new biography takes entirely the opposite view. It convincingly portrays George as intelligent, benevolent, scrupulously devoted to the constitution of his country and (as head of government as well as head of state) navigating the turbulence of eighteenth-century politics with a strong sense of honour and duty. He was a devoted husband and family man, a great patron of the arts and sciences, keen ('Farmer George') to advance Britain's agricultural capacity and determined that her horizons should be global.
The book gives a detailed, revisionist account of the American War of Independence, amongst other things persuasively taking apart a significant proportion of the Declaration of Independence. In a later war, it shows how George's support for William Pitt was crucial to the battle against Napoleon. And it makes a credible, modern diagnosis of George's terrible malady which robbed him of his mind for the last 10 years of his life - his other main claim to the popular imagination.
Roberts argues that, far from being a tyrant or incompetent, George III was one of our most admirable monarchs. George III shows one of Britain's premier historians at his sparkling best.
1 有用 lowai 2022-01-05 11:35:53
超级好看, 主要讲George III和大臣们之间的关系, 包含了很多18世纪英国Whigs和Tories之间的斗争. 按作者的说法, George给人的坏印象很大程度来自Whig历史学家和美国人 (作者本身并不相信Whig史观, 即进步是人类发展的核心), 这本书就是要改变人们的印象. 这点上作者做得相当好, 读完真给人一种noble sovereign的感觉. 当然改变对君主本身就有厌恶偏见的... 超级好看, 主要讲George III和大臣们之间的关系, 包含了很多18世纪英国Whigs和Tories之间的斗争. 按作者的说法, George给人的坏印象很大程度来自Whig历史学家和美国人 (作者本身并不相信Whig史观, 即进步是人类发展的核心), 这本书就是要改变人们的印象. 这点上作者做得相当好, 读完真给人一种noble sovereign的感觉. 当然改变对君主本身就有厌恶偏见的人的印象肯定很难, 毕竟从谁身上都能挖出自己不喜欢的部分. 最后附加的一个反驳George癫疯是卟啉病的附录非常好. 一些读后感: (a)原来国王这么有文化; (b)Whig真不是东西, 特别是Fox; (c)Pitt the Younger真是救星; (d)独立宣言充满污蔑, 美国真是生于不义 (展开)
0 有用 Walmeriette 2023-07-12 14:54:08 日本
一言以蔽之:爹心善。不过罗伯茨不说废话的时候的确是气势磅礴的。