In Undoing Suicidism, Alexandre Baril argues that suicidal people are oppressed by what he calls structural suicidism, a hidden oppression that, until now, has been unnamed and under-theorized. Each year, suicidism and its preventionist script and strategies reproduce violence and cause additional harm and death among suicidal people through forms of criminalization, incarceration, discrimination, stigmatization, and pathologization. This is particularly true for marginalized groups experiencing multiple oppressions, including queer, trans, disabled, or Mad people.
Undoing Suicidism questions the belief that the best way to help suicidal people is through the logic of prevention. Alexandre Baril presents the thought-provoking argument that supporting assisted suicide for suicidal people could better prevent unnecessary deaths. Offering a new queercrip model of (assisted) suicide, he invites us to imagine what could happen if we started thinking about (assisted) suicide from an anti-suicidist and intersectional framework.
Baril provides a radical reconceptualization of (assisted) suicide and invaluable reflections for academics, activists, practitioners, and policymakers.
3 有用 Cory 2024-04-11 14:55:18 上海
作者开篇便“出柜”为一名长期有自杀倾向的跨性别双性恋残障男性,全天戴着“拒绝急救”手环。全书从酷儿理论、残障研究、疯癫研究视角考察了看待自杀的几种范式(包括左翼进步运动内部的看法)对有自杀意念者的认识论暴力。作者倡导positive right to suicide(有自杀意念者不仅不该被强行阻止,而且有权获得协助),也批判了当下的死亡权利运动基于健康状况的可弃性(disposability)逻辑... 作者开篇便“出柜”为一名长期有自杀倾向的跨性别双性恋残障男性,全天戴着“拒绝急救”手环。全书从酷儿理论、残障研究、疯癫研究视角考察了看待自杀的几种范式(包括左翼进步运动内部的看法)对有自杀意念者的认识论暴力。作者倡导positive right to suicide(有自杀意念者不仅不该被强行阻止,而且有权获得协助),也批判了当下的死亡权利运动基于健康状况的可弃性(disposability)逻辑。较有收获的是suicidism、compulsory aliveness对主流的自杀干预观给出了清晰扼要的命名,且勾勒出这套规范如何与其它规范交叉,讨论ontology of assisted suicide的部分也有启发。作者直言希望此书对非专业读者也简明易懂,行文有时略显拖沓重复,综述感较重。 (展开)
0 有用 gansen 2024-06-12 20:04:09 日本
真不懂这本书哪里radical了。难不成只是因为当事者身份?
0 有用 Lucien在昂古莱 2024-06-14 16:59:00 北京
期待越高失望越大,提出suicidism这个框架、拒绝将suicidality扁平化为交叉结构性压迫的后果确实很重要,除此之外这书写二十页都嫌长,如同读两百页行文差劲分析也乏善可陈的lit review,急需一个编辑来修剪语句重复