The eighteenth-century Hongloumeng, known in English as Dream of the Red Chamber or The Story of the Stone, is generally considered to be the greatest of Chinese novels—one that masterfully blends realism and romance, psychological motivation and fate, daily life and mythical occurrences, as it narrates the decline of a powerful Chinese family. In this path-breaking study, Anthony Yu goes beyond the customary view of Hongloumeng as a vivid reflection of late imperial Chinese culture by examining the novel as a story about fictive representation. Through a maze of literary devices, the novel challenges the authority of history as well as referential biases in reading. At the heart of Hongloumeng, Yu argues, is the narration of desire. Desire appears in this tale as the defining trait and problem of human beings and at the same time shapes the novel’s literary invention and effect. According to Yu, this focalizing treatment of desire may well be Hongloumeng’s most distinctive accomplishment.
Through close readings of selected episodes, Yu analyzes principal motifs of the narrative, such as dream, mirror, literature, religious enlightenment, and rhetorical reflexivity in relation to fictive representation. He contextualizes his discussions with a comprehensive genealogy of qing—desire, disposition, sentiment, feeling—a concept of fundamental importance in historical Chinese culture, and shows how the text ingeniously exploits its multiple meanings. Spanning a wide range of comparative literary sources, Yu creates a new conceptual framework in which to reevaluate this masterpiece.
4 有用 伢栗野 2024-01-12 01:16:54 美国
有点不得要领。。强调红楼梦作为虚构的autoreferentiality,作为“allegory of reading”,提供一种关于小说本身的理论,第三章讲石头和虚构很有意思,但是有点没懂虚构和情欲的关系是啥(第四章专门讲这个但是也没太懂具体结论是啥),以及跟第二章梳理的情和欲的谱系有啥关系(欲本身并非不道德的,反而道德本身就是一种欲)。。虽然作者说并非附会西方理论,但是也许红楼梦和西方文学/理... 有点不得要领。。强调红楼梦作为虚构的autoreferentiality,作为“allegory of reading”,提供一种关于小说本身的理论,第三章讲石头和虚构很有意思,但是有点没懂虚构和情欲的关系是啥(第四章专门讲这个但是也没太懂具体结论是啥),以及跟第二章梳理的情和欲的谱系有啥关系(欲本身并非不道德的,反而道德本身就是一种欲)。。虽然作者说并非附会西方理论,但是也许红楼梦和西方文学/理论的呼应本身有其历史线索?以及觉得有点好笑经常“a modern critic”匿名引文,低头一看脚注是paul de man and foucault (展开)
0 有用 離微 2014-04-03 08:41:48
Required reading for Prof. Robert Hegel's seminar on Honglou meng this semester. Prof. Yu's Rereading of the story of the Stone ABSOLUTELY worth rereading!!
1 有用 纳西小伙 2026-01-03 21:57:12 北京
2025.12.31 从哈萨克斯坦阿拉木图到乌鲁木齐长途巴士中深夜读完。余国藩意图挑战红楼梦自传式阅读策略而强调其反复自我证成且持续深入探索的虚构性;脂砚斋的点评口吻引诱读者相信共享秘密而非共情理解作为恰当阐释路径,然而读者群体和阅读过程差异正能释放文本阅读可能性;文本似真虚构策略作为媒介以虚构属性强化真理可信度,梦境和现实的绝对不可分辨性使得通过欲望而非绝对弃绝通达开悟成为可能。重读红楼梦本身值... 2025.12.31 从哈萨克斯坦阿拉木图到乌鲁木齐长途巴士中深夜读完。余国藩意图挑战红楼梦自传式阅读策略而强调其反复自我证成且持续深入探索的虚构性;脂砚斋的点评口吻引诱读者相信共享秘密而非共情理解作为恰当阐释路径,然而读者群体和阅读过程差异正能释放文本阅读可能性;文本似真虚构策略作为媒介以虚构属性强化真理可信度,梦境和现实的绝对不可分辨性使得通过欲望而非绝对弃绝通达开悟成为可能。重读红楼梦本身值得反复重读,不仅缘于余国藩对于西方文学理论和中国文学思想史及其宏广的旁征博引,更发端于他局部清晰易懂但整体论述功能隐晦的书写风格使得应对学术八股快速把握论述要点的阅读策略缺乏施展空间;不断重读以汲取思想闪光和激发思考或许是更为恰当地面对本书的合理技巧。 (展开)
0 有用 ClementeMoneta 2021-12-18 10:58:48
补标
0 有用 迷之女主角X 2021-12-14 08:53:05
说好的重读石头记,感觉没有读到很有启发性的阐释。读来总有点东一榔头西一棒槌的感觉,比如第二章那个建构“情”的知识考古的lengthy excursus,谈到梦又一会说庄子一会说金刚经一会又跳到楞伽经。