作者:
Johannes Fabian 出版社: Columbia University Press 副标题: How Anthropology Makes Its Object 出版年: 2002-4-15 页数: 205 定价: USD 33.00 装帧: Paperback ISBN: 9780231125772
Fabian's study is a classic in the field that changed the way anthropologists relate to their subjects and is of immense value not only to anthropologists but to all those concerned with the study of man. A new foreward by Matti Bunzl brings the influence of Fabian's study up to the present. Time and the Other is a critique of the notions that anthropologists are "here and now,...
Fabian's study is a classic in the field that changed the way anthropologists relate to their subjects and is of immense value not only to anthropologists but to all those concerned with the study of man. A new foreward by Matti Bunzl brings the influence of Fabian's study up to the present. Time and the Other is a critique of the notions that anthropologists are "here and now," their objects of study are "there and then," and that the "other" exists in a time not contemporary with our own.
Fabian's argument is motivated by a contradiction inherent to the anthropological discipline: on the one hand, anthropological knowledge is produced in the course of fieldwork through the intersubjective communication between anthropologists and interlocutors; on the other hand, traditional forms of ethnographic representation require the constitutive suppression of the dialogical realities generating anthropological insights in the first place. In the objectifying discourses of a scientistic anthropology, "Others" thus never appear as immediate partners in a cultural exchange but as spatially and, more importantly, temporally distanced groups. (查看原文)
联想到Edward Said "The Orientalism"，好像Fabian给书中描述的现象做出了解释，其成因便是他的主要论点the differentiation of time，再一个就是他俩都对被研究对象自我描述/陈述的能力对这种文化之间双向或单方向的交流有所讨论。再缩小范围想到一个社会内同样的这种"we" con...
(展开)
哲夫成城
北京师范大学出版社2018版
springjournal
0 有用 毛绒榕 2018-11-04 16:21:24
磕磕巴巴读完了 好
0 有用 亚露 2011-06-20 08:39:55
比历史教科书有深度
0 有用 城市笔记人 2008-10-16 14:25:39
classic in symbolic anthropology
1 有用 日照充足 2022-02-11 14:23:06
Coevality 不同于simultaneity- 后者对时间的同质化，前者则是与他者时间遭遇的基本条件所在。
1 有用 sub rosa 2016-10-13 21:29:50
@ starry
0 有用 鄭巨源 2023-09-23 16:13:22 浙江
虽然具体论述和章节安排略显杂乱，但全书呈现的理念和方法论极为精妙，值得重读。
0 有用 Yours, Miran 2023-03-30 06:31:55 美国
提醒自己：一定要重新再讀
0 有用 世相 2022-04-01 10:11:31
Chap 1 & 4. 不是想象中的visualism...第一章还算有趣，只是路数太practical了一些。可以和Wolf People without History联动。
1 有用 日照充足 2022-02-11 14:23:06
Coevality 不同于simultaneity- 后者对时间的同质化，前者则是与他者时间遭遇的基本条件所在。
0 有用 Odysseus 2021-07-11 01:19:00
日文版把nostalgic gesture翻译为乡愁，有点美。