Unpacking Queer Politics argues that the strong lesbian feminist movement of the 1970s, which was able to articulate a philosophy and practice that distinguished lesbian politics from gay male politics, was submerged in the 1990s beneath a gay male agenda called queer politics.
The new politics repudiated lesbian feminist ideas and celebrated 'manhood' as a goal for gay men. Practices which construct this 'manhood', such as sadomasochism, cutting and piercing, female-to-male transsexual surgery, and which are promoted in queer politics, need to be understood as forms of self-harm which result from the oppression of lesbians and gay men. The political agenda of queer politics is damaging to the interests of lesbians, women in general, and to marginalized and vulnerable constituencies of gay men.
The book concludes by arguing that precisely the commitment to equality in relationships and sex that has been so important to lesbian feminists, and so excoriated in much of queer theory, should form the basis of a social transformation. In this way lesbians should be seen as the vanguard of social change.
0 有用 momo 2026-09-06 21:28:06 山东
比Gender Hurts更值得读,尤其是作为铺垫溯源女同女权历史成因的第一章,对当前国内rf与lf争端有参考价值。相比于社会调查,这本更倾向于梳理历史脉络。即便国内外对酷儿政治的批判分析已经不算新鲜,考虑到著作发表的年份,不可谓不高瞻远瞩。
0 有用 二一 2026-09-13 22:55:32 江西
女性情谊的污名化与女性解放同步发生,而非偶然
0 有用 JumpandScream 2026-02-04 16:04:40 湖北
zlib有中译版,但是存在AI漏翻句子段落、自由再创作的问题。
2 有用 一个苹果🍎 2025-12-29 22:56:51 湖南
写于 2003 年的一本超前作品,一句话总结就是酷儿文化抛弃了最初想要打破性别角色的野心转而拥抱了充满了男性崇拜的男同文化并将其包装为先锋前卫包容。
1 有用 發財 2025-11-16 09:54:15 荷兰
是真的unpacking...写很长但概括就是queer theory跟lesbian feminist诉求冲突(无论是for lesbian 还是for feminist)...是父权的、异性恋中心主义的、对资本主义献媚讨好的。还有很多细节且很有信息的东西就不提了,写太多太长了,印象深的比如其实FTM和butch其实很难划出界限,那么性别认同和取向认同界限到底又在何处,以及以及更多更多的东西,一... 是真的unpacking...写很长但概括就是queer theory跟lesbian feminist诉求冲突(无论是for lesbian 还是for feminist)...是父权的、异性恋中心主义的、对资本主义献媚讨好的。还有很多细节且很有信息的东西就不提了,写太多太长了,印象深的比如其实FTM和butch其实很难划出界限,那么性别认同和取向认同界限到底又在何处,以及以及更多更多的东西,一本烂账算不清的原因是一开始的框子就找错了。现在简中很多人喜欢拿伞式概念来解释,但问题伞式就只是伞式,内在冲突就不只是“小冲突”,很可能根本不兼容,比如Straight trans也是算进来的。。也是绝对异性恋中心主义。如果说缺点的话觉得theory可以写更多(虽然已经很锐),案例和综述性质的可减少。 (展开)