The Body Multiple is an extraordinary ethnography of an ordinary disease. Drawing on fieldwork in a Dutch university hospital, Annemarie Mol looks at the day-to-day diagnosis and treatment of atherosclerosis. A patient information leaflet might describe atherosclerosis as the gradual obstruction of the arteries, but in hospital practice this one medical condition appears to be many other things as well. From one moment, place, apparatus, specialty, or treatment to the next, a slightly different "atherosclerosis" is being discussed, measured, observed, or stripped away. Mol demonstrates that this multiplicity does not imply fragmentation. Instead, the disease is made to cohere through a range of tactics including transporting forms and files, making images, holding case conferences, and conducting doctor-patient conversations. The Body Multiple juxtaposes two distinct texts. Alongside Mol's analysis of her ethnographic material - interviews with doctors and patients; observations of medical examinations, consultations, and operations - runs a parallel text in which she reflects on the relevant literature. Mol draws on medical anthropology, sociology, feminist theory, philosophy, and science and technology studies to reframe such issues as the disease-illness distinction, subject-object relations, boundaries, difference, situatedness, and ontology. In dialogue with one another, Mol's two texts meditate on the multiplicity of reality-in-practice. Presenting philosophical reflections on the body and medical practice through vivid storytelling, The Body Multiple will be important to those in medical anthropology, philosophy, and the social study of science, technology, and medicine.
2 有用 makzhou 2020-08-09 17:13:17
很有意思,让人产生诸多联想的研究。以动脉硬化的诊断和治疗为例谈医疗知识。写法上很很新奇,正文分上下两部分,上面谈case,下面谈传统/文献,都很有启发。现在我更感兴趣的是这个部分:「Analyzing medicine as enacting different realities and different ways of qualifying the good is not just a wa... 很有意思,让人产生诸多联想的研究。以动脉硬化的诊断和治疗为例谈医疗知识。写法上很很新奇,正文分上下两部分,上面谈case,下面谈传统/文献,都很有启发。现在我更感兴趣的是这个部分:「Analyzing medicine as enacting different realities and different ways of qualifying the good is not just a way of talking about medicine but also a way of talking inside it.」 (展开)
1 有用 老爹 2020-12-28 07:56:57
今年最后一本书了吧…all about ‘empirical philosophy’, practicality and physicality.
0 有用 eyesickick 2023-02-04 11:44:00 美国
理论部分写的很扎实,但这部分扫读的,有时间要再读。民族志部分田野感觉做的好扎实啊…不过这个排版方式对编辑是个灾难吧哈哈哈empirical philosophy; ontology-in-practice; reality multiples; enactments; praxiograph; manyfolderness (the body/singular is multiple/many);... 理论部分写的很扎实,但这部分扫读的,有时间要再读。民族志部分田野感觉做的好扎实啊…不过这个排版方式对编辑是个灾难吧哈哈哈empirical philosophy; ontology-in-practice; reality multiples; enactments; praxiograph; manyfolderness (the body/singular is multiple/many); goodnesses; a politics of what. (展开)
0 有用 鸿音 2019-08-04 06:08:57
实验室的研究、临床诊断、治疗和病人体验呈现出的是完全不同的动脉粥状硬化,因而在具体实践中politics of who 的视角就需要转移到politics of what。在这个意义上单个疾病可以是“多样的”,身体也可以是“多样的”而不是多元的(一个器官可以引发某种疾病,而疾病在身体不同部位有不同表现,这些表现不是割裂的,但又自成一个“世界”,对不同的人意味着不同的本体论)。上下分离的排版实在难受... 实验室的研究、临床诊断、治疗和病人体验呈现出的是完全不同的动脉粥状硬化,因而在具体实践中politics of who 的视角就需要转移到politics of what。在这个意义上单个疾病可以是“多样的”,身体也可以是“多样的”而不是多元的(一个器官可以引发某种疾病,而疾病在身体不同部位有不同表现,这些表现不是割裂的,但又自成一个“世界”,对不同的人意味着不同的本体论)。上下分离的排版实在难受,我已经尽力去理解了。然而给我的感受就是虽然似曾相识但也有点道理我竟无言以对。 (展开)
10 有用 一一姑娘 2015-12-05 21:56:51
绝对是今年看的最有帮助的书了,帮助我把研究框架搭建了起来。通过人类学民族志观察把一个哲学问题分析的非常深入,也非常简洁直白。搞哲学搞到这份上太让人感动了……