‘When we claim to have been injured by language, what kind of claim do we make?’ - Judith Butler, Excitable Speech
Excitable Speech is widely hailed as a tour de force and one of Judith Butler’s most important books. Examining in turn debates about hate speech, pornography and gayness within the US military, Butler argues that words can wound and linguistic violence is its own kind of violence. Yet she also argues that speech is ‘excitable’ and fluid, because its effects often are beyond the control of the speaker, shaped by fantasy, context and power structures.
In a novel and courageous move, she urges caution concerning the use of legislation to restrict and censor speech, especially in cases where injurious language is taken up by aesthetic practices to diminish and oppose the injury, such as in rap and popular music. Although speech can insult and demean, it is also a form of recognition and may be used to talk back; injurious speech can reinforce power structures, but it can also repeat power in ways that separate language from its injurious power. Skillfully showing how language’s oppositional power resides in its insubordinate and dynamic nature and its capacity to appropriate and defuse words that usually wound, Butler also seeks to account for why some clearly hateful speech is taken to be iconic of free speech, while other forms are more easily submitted to censorship.
In light of current debates between advocates of freedom of speech and ‘no platform’ and cancel culture, the message of Excitable Speech remains more relevant now than ever.
This Routledge Classics edition includes a new Preface by the author, where she considers speech and language in the context contemporary forms of political polarization.
Review
"In her extraordinary new book, Excitable Speech, Judith Butler... looks conceptually at speech, and she has plenty to say... Excitable Speech offers a thoughtful consideration of the ways in which speech and speaking are used by all points on the political spectrum to further political ends." - The Bay Guardian
"Makes a valuable contribution... No-one should ignore Judith Butler's analysis and conclusions." - The Women's Review of Books
"Butler's exploration of racist, sexist, and homophobic language is hence of acute significance to anyone concerned with the sociopolitical and theoretical implications of hate speech." - The Lesbian Review of Books
"This book offers a challenging analysis of the free speech debates. As she moves from the often frightening contradictions in legal arguments to the visceral pain caused by hate speech, Butler makes a compelling case that our laws--and our lives--are determined by conceptual frameworks." - Lambda Book Report
"This sober and subtle work draws us into the dark heart of a world where words wound, images enrage, and speech is haunted by hate. Butler intervenes brilliantly in an argument that tests the limits of both legal claims and linguistic acts. She explores the link between 'reasons' of state and the passions of personhood as she meditates on utterance as a form of incitement, excitement, and injury. There is a fine urgency here that expands our understanding of the place of the 'affective' in the realm of public events." - Homi K. Bhabha, Harvard University, USA
"Judith Butler has brilliantly challenged us to rethink our conventional ideas about the power of speech. As is to be expected of Butler, Excitable Speech is original, witty, and lucidly argued. This book is essential reading for anyone concerned with the politics of free speech." - Drucilla Cornell, Rutgers University School of Law, USA
"If to speak is to act, what follows? In this shrewd and compelling book, Judith butler, the philosopher of Queer Theory and the performative theory of gender, takes up the thorniest problems of our day concerning the relation between speech and action, such as hate speech, pornography, and the military's policy that makes a declaration of homosexuality a punishable act. Her analyses are brilliant engagements that refuse to oversimplify and show us that politics requires serious thinking." - Jonathan Culler, Cornell University, USA
"Flag burning and cross burning; pornography and coming out; racial taunts and AIDS education; using 'racial classifications' and remaining 'race blind': this book will provide constitutional and legislative debates about regulating these forms of 'injurious speech' with a brilliantly nuanced analysis of language as action. Butler has provided us with a sustained demonstration that we should fill in the moat that separates law schools from the human sciences, and quickly." - Janet Halley, Harvard Law School, USA
"In this relentlessly intelligent analysis of hate speech, Judith Butler proposes a speech act theory of verbal injury that is not dependent on the grammar of accountability. There is never a slack moment in this brilliant book." - Barbara Johnson, Harvard University, USA
1 有用 Hier Tanze 2022-03-18 15:58:34
语言并非个人所控制,法律的机制是制造主体,使其承担因果道德责任,以此掩盖社会权力运作本身。军队中的同性恋禁令实际上以禁止的方式保留同性欲望。审查之为审查在于其隐性一面,它先行划定了可能的言说和不可能的言说的规范,使不可能之物无法被分辨。对侮辱性语言的反对,仅借助于法律审查是远不足的,要依靠“言语行为的开放时间性”,因为意指链本身是一个不稳定的过程,我们便可在不同语境下重新征引语词,实现再赋义。勇敢... 语言并非个人所控制,法律的机制是制造主体,使其承担因果道德责任,以此掩盖社会权力运作本身。军队中的同性恋禁令实际上以禁止的方式保留同性欲望。审查之为审查在于其隐性一面,它先行划定了可能的言说和不可能的言说的规范,使不可能之物无法被分辨。对侮辱性语言的反对,仅借助于法律审查是远不足的,要依靠“言语行为的开放时间性”,因为意指链本身是一个不稳定的过程,我们便可在不同语境下重新征引语词,实现再赋义。勇敢接受某些污名,并把它转化为勇敢和反叛,正如Queer一词那样。语言的确是社会斗争的不可还原的领域。不过,巴特勒没有说明,符号和其他所指物的重新链接究竟如何得以可能;如果一切都是操演,反抗的主体何来?断言式的判断似乎也总在走向某种A就是B的本质主义和关系单向性,现实的复杂被颠覆性的思想尖刺覆盖。 (展开)
1 有用 Hier Tanze 2022-03-18 15:58:34
语言并非个人所控制,法律的机制是制造主体,使其承担因果道德责任,以此掩盖社会权力运作本身。军队中的同性恋禁令实际上以禁止的方式保留同性欲望。审查之为审查在于其隐性一面,它先行划定了可能的言说和不可能的言说的规范,使不可能之物无法被分辨。对侮辱性语言的反对,仅借助于法律审查是远不足的,要依靠“言语行为的开放时间性”,因为意指链本身是一个不稳定的过程,我们便可在不同语境下重新征引语词,实现再赋义。勇敢... 语言并非个人所控制,法律的机制是制造主体,使其承担因果道德责任,以此掩盖社会权力运作本身。军队中的同性恋禁令实际上以禁止的方式保留同性欲望。审查之为审查在于其隐性一面,它先行划定了可能的言说和不可能的言说的规范,使不可能之物无法被分辨。对侮辱性语言的反对,仅借助于法律审查是远不足的,要依靠“言语行为的开放时间性”,因为意指链本身是一个不稳定的过程,我们便可在不同语境下重新征引语词,实现再赋义。勇敢接受某些污名,并把它转化为勇敢和反叛,正如Queer一词那样。语言的确是社会斗争的不可还原的领域。不过,巴特勒没有说明,符号和其他所指物的重新链接究竟如何得以可能;如果一切都是操演,反抗的主体何来?断言式的判断似乎也总在走向某种A就是B的本质主义和关系单向性,现实的复杂被颠覆性的思想尖刺覆盖。 (展开)