Many people who agree that the family is desirable as an instrument for the transmission of morals, tastes, and knowledge still question the desirability of the transmission of material property. Yet there can be little doubt that, in order that the former may be possible, some continuity of standards, of the external forms of life, is essential, and that this will be achieved only if it is possible to transmit not only immaterial but also material advantages. There is, of course, neither greater merit nor any greater injustice involved in some people being born to wealthy parents than there is in others being born to kind or intelligent parents. The fact is that it is no less of an advantage to the community if at least some children can start with the advantages which at any given time o... (查看原文)
We are not concerned here with the chief argument for private inheritance, namely, that it seems essential as a means to preserve the dispersal in the control of capital and as an inducement for its accumulation. Rather, our concern here is whether the fact that it confers unmerited benefits on some is a valid argument against the institution. It is unquestionably one of the institutional causes of inequality. In the present context we need not inquire whether liberty demands unlimited freedom of bequest. Our problem here is merely whether people ought to be free to pass on to children or others such material possessions as will cause substantial inequality. (查看原文)
109 有用 華洋折衷 2020-04-16 16:12:36
短评有个ID叫风清扬的用户,此书的成立为何会使社会学成为伪科学,你无法从逻辑层面接受哈耶克也就罢了,还妄下如此定论。
1 有用 (¯﹃¯) 2012-03-13 22:19:33
假期看了大半就搁下了,今晚趁马春文在讲台各种侃绪论导论还有宏观经济学的发展史,就在他提及奥派的时候侧耳听了一下,这两天终于把这本书啃完了我容易么我。内容很好可是翻译实在晦涩了,尼玛一句话三行字,读完一句呼吸好几次了。不过作为哈耶克信徒,我还是看的很哈皮,深有所得。
0 有用 kiddy 2007-11-19 12:56:16
去年仔细读读处理最后之人就是这本来,应用部分尚未读。最近听到VIVO网友对此书的批评,巨沮丧。
20 有用 风清扬 2011-08-25 15:39:57
此书若成立,那社会学必然要成为伪科学~
0 有用 Sid 2015-10-27 22:58:28
老师的教科书 爱 - "我们虽不能在黑暗中视见,但却一定能够探寻出黑暗区域的范围"
0 有用 飞扬 2023-08-21 11:15:55 山东
集中体现了哈耶克的思想
0 有用 豆友270625758 2023-07-03 14:12:01 福建
感谢邓正来先生的翻译
0 有用 苏打水ph8 2023-05-12 12:17:21 北京
读了第一部分的前三章和第二部分,邓正来先生翻译的很好。
0 有用 sunsky 2023-04-28 19:05:08 福建
“只有当人们超越了其此在的自我时,亦即只有当新颖者得以产生且对他的评价也有待于未来时,自由才会最终显示出其自身的价值。”一些内容没有完全理解,似乎本书的论证也不是十分清晰,但是无疑其批判的很多东西在当下仍是盛行,其预期的后果很多在当下也发生了。
0 有用 不想读书的阿美 2023-04-09 10:34:17 浙江
读了平等价值与品行